Quirks of the Garmin

On February 25, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

I’m back to the work week routine and despite the residual fatigue that comes from rising at 4:00 AM I’ve settled back in to my running program. Although I am pleased with the Garmin 50 I’ve experienced some frustration with its operation, mostly due to its complex interface and its too simple instruction manual.

There are four buttons on the watch that do different things based upon the mode: time, training, intervals, etc. It is not obvious to the user which sequence of buttons need to be pushed to start an action, check a performance metric or calibrate the unit. The manual doesn’t cover much of what the watch can do so I’m left frustrated knowing I’m not getting everything I can from the watch. In some cases the frustration comes from inconsistancies with the interface. For example, when in training mode, the usual default screen displays 0000:00:00 meaning “hit start and run.” It then records distance, speed, cadence and pulse rate and will display any of those metrics by toggling with one button. That’s great except when that display doesn’t show up when you switch to training mode.

This morning I got going on the treadmill, brought the speed to my normal starting pace, switched the Garmin to “Train” and was annoyed to see that it did not give me my expected start display. So as I’m running at about a 6.5 mi/hr pace I’m jabbing at the watch in hopes of correcting this so I can record my run. Eventually I noticed a different display that seemed to be capturing distance so I left it alone and in the end it allowed me to save the run. The aggrevating part was that I ran at least .3 miles while this all played out and consequently none of that data was captured.

I’ll see exactly what it did capture once the run is uploaded to Garmin Connect. I’m sure I’ll eventually learn every aspect of the watch through trial and error but I’m puzzled by the lack of operational documentation. I wonder how many Garmin users give up on the features simply because the thing’s so darn complicated.

The 20 minute challenge

On February 23, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

The alarm went off at 3:55 AM this morning for the first time in over a week. I was surprised that I had some energy and I decided to run instead of elliptical (which I usually do on Mondays) because I hadn’t yet recorded a treadmill run on the Garmin. Actually I had done that on Sunday but my lack of familiarity with the watch controls caused me to delete the run before it could be uploaded to Garmin Connect. That was annoying but it was only a mile so I didn’t care. This morning I ran about 2 miles within my tight 20 minute window. Over the last nine days I became a little spoiled with the amount of time I had to run so I felt some stress to get my distance in today. I didn’t get a chance to review my average pace or any other workout data because I had to move along but I’ll do that tonight after I upload. I’m concerned that Garmin Connect will only accept the most recent run, unlike the Nike Sportband that would accumulate the runs and upload them in batch. That is until it stopped uploading at all.

Despite the short amount of time I had available this morning I’m happy with my run. Tomorrow I’ll elliptical at resistance level of 10. So much for looking forward to easy workouts on elliptical days.

Don’t try this at home

On February 10, 2009 By Emerging Runner5 Comments

Yesterday morning I attended the Amazon press event where they unveiled their newest Kindle reader. Jeff Bezos, founder and CEO of Amazon, demonstrated the device and he talked about how people use the Kindle. He said that people can use it while on the treadmill and I tried unsuccessfully to think of a scenrio where that would not end badly. I don’t know about anyone else but when I’m on the treadmill there is very little opportunity to focus on reading. Besides that, I’m guessing that the percussive force from running would likely vibrate a device right off the holder. Every time I run indoors the clock across the room turns, moves or falls off the bedside table.

The writer, Stephen King, followed Bezos on stage and he also talked about reading with the Kindle on the treadmill. Maybe it works for walkers. I’m going to try an experiment this weekend to try to read the NY Times or Fortune magazine on my Kindle while I run. If it works I’ll gladly retract my skepticism.

The persistance of treadmill memory

On January 19, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

My apologies for writing such a bad Dali pun as a headline but I have discovered something interesting about treadmill data. The cold weather and snow that we have experienced this past week has forced me to spend a lot of time running indoors. The treadmill is clearly a subject for discussion as most people view it either as an enabler or a necessary evil but you can’t argue with its convenience. After using it as my third choice after street and track for months I realized that my basic assumption of its measurement accuracy is flawed. I’ve always assumed that maintaining a constant speed on the treadmill will accomplish the same for the runner. In other words, assuming the reading is accurate, when the treadmill says 7 MPH you’re running 7 MPH.

The treadmill forces you to run (as long as the tread is moving you’d better be running) but there can be a measurable variance in treadmill speed and runner speed. I noticed this on Saturday when I had a strong start and after a mile my Sportband showed my distance about .05 miles ahead of the treadmill’s. Throughout the run I saw that gap begin to close and at 2.7 miles the treadmill distance began to exceed the Sportband distance. This intrigued me and also annoyed me because I knew I’d need to run a little extra at the end to achieve my planned distance. After thinking about it I realized it makes sense. You don’t have to run the same pace of the treadmill as you run on it as long as your feet are moving. There is a minimum speed you’ll need to maintain lest you get swept off the tread but there’s some latitude there. My experience showed me where I peak in terms of pace and where I begin to lose speed over time. Knowing this will help me better tune my performance by pushing my crossover time further and further into my run.

I was hoping to run on the track today but, like yesterday, we’ve received another few inches of snow. I ran about 3.5 miles yesterday on top of Saturday’s 3.6. I may shoot for longer distance today or go the other way and cross train with the elliptical and the shovel.

In defense of the treadmill

On January 15, 2009 By Emerging Runner3 Comments

The temperature this morning was in the low teens with winds making it far colder. It was also snowing which surprised me a little since I’ve always thought it couldn’t snow when the temperature dropped much below freezing. Adding to this was the 4:00 AM darkness creating the most inhospitable running environment that can be found in suburban NY. There was no question that I would run on the treadmill as the darkness alone is enough to keep me inside on weekday mornings. Also, I like the treadmill for reasons I’ll address further into this post.

As a re-engaged runner I am interested in what more experienced runners think and what they do. I’m always curious to hear real runner’s opinions about treadmills because I’ve found them to be a divisive subject. There are those who just hate them and won’t use them unless every alternative is exhausted. I know a person who runs in every kind of weather and who won’t even wear a hat or long pants unless the temperature drops below 10 degrees. A couple of friends that are well established runners avoid the treadmill because they think the motion of the tread throws off their technique. I respect them very much and I’ve learned greatly from them both but I don’t agree with that perspective.

The treadmill makes great sense to me because it’s a practical and enabling technology. It lets me run when nature doesn’t cooperate. Perhaps more importantly, the treadmill gives me full control of my environment in terms of conditions, speed and effort. I often think about the movie “2001: A Space Odyssey” where Keir Dullea runs within a space station as it revolves. This morning I realized that I would run out of time before hitting my minimum distance for my weekday run. I had about five minutes left and saw that I was about 3/10ths of a mile short of my goal. With reckless abandon I pushed the speed control to 7.8 mph which is close to a 7:30/mi pace. I ended up covering much more distance than originally planned. I know it’s not the same as the street or track but that doesn’t mean it’s worse. One established runner I know tells me she finds the treadmill workout harder than the street. I know it’s not ideal and will always prefer the view of the neighborhood, the athletic field or (I’m guessing) the trail to the static view of my backyard viewed through the guestroom window. But at 4:00 AM with snow and a freezing wind-chill I’m still running.

Running in the great indoors

On December 20, 2008 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

We’ve had a few snowstorms already this year despite the fact that winter doesn’t even start until Sunday. With 3+ inches of snow on the street I needed to stay indoors for today’s run. I actually enjoy the treadmill and although the view doesn’t change it was still nice to look into the backyard (see above) and watch the snow falling. I also like that I don’t need to put on layers of running gear when I run inside. A short sleeve wicking shirt and running shorts were sufficient and I opened windows at both ends of the room to let in that 23 degree outside air as a way to stay cool. As I was watching the snow I began to think about the need to reserve some energy for shoveling. But of course I didn’t.

This morning I ran 3 miles at 9:26/mi which is not bad considering that I shoveled snow twice yesterday plus I ran about the same distance as I did today. No muscle pull issues either. I’m glad I listened to my friends about respecting the injury. I wonder if anyone ever runs outdoors when there’s this much snow on the ground. Seems risky but, like running in the rain, kinda fun.

My fake 5K

On December 8, 2008 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

Given the snow and the cold I did my running indoors yesterday. My goal this weekend was to duplicate a 5K run which I was hoping to do on the street or on the track. I did it on the treadmill instead and while I was pleased that I had enough energy to keep going at the end point I recognized that conditions (softer surface, belt motion, no hills) made this an ideal rather than representative run. On the other hand, it’s cooler to run outdoors this time of year which is why I prefer to run that way.

Comparing indoor versus outdoor running

On December 2, 2008 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

I was out of the office most of last week for the Thanksgiving break. Days off give me more time to run outside and I think that it’s important to balance indoor treadmill running with pavement running. The experiences are very different, the view on the treadmill (Pro-Form L18) doesn’t change (unless TV counts) while my outdoor runs are almost always unique in terms of route. The treadmill is a more forgiving and enabling process since the tread itself is more padded than pavement and the motion of the tread provides momentum for the runner. On the other hand outdoor running provides a variety of conditions (elevations, weather, terrain) that can be positive (or negative) distractions.