It’s not the shoes, it’s the runner

On August 30, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

A conversation I had this morning at Super Runner’s Shop in Huntington, NY and an article in today’s New York Times were not connected but similar in subject. My conversation centered around a question I’d asked regarding the performance properties of shoes. I mentioned that I bought a pair of Brooks GTS 9’s in April but never felt that they matched the Nike Turbulence 13’s they replaced in terms of responsiveness. The person at the store said it was unlikely that a pair of running shoes would make much of a difference unless I’d switched to very lightweight trainers that lack cushioning and are made for competitive runners. The Times article “Wiggling Their Toes at the Shoe Giants” made that point a different way citing the emerging popularity of minimalist shoes that mimic the effect of running barefoot. The article mentions companies like Vibram, Feelmax and Terra Plana who have “barefoot running” style products along with Nike, who have found a growing demand for its trainer, the “Free.” The article posits a view that modern running shoes do not prevent injuries or promote performance any better than when modern running shoes were introduced 40 years ago. Later in the article is a counter argument that only biomechanically efficient runners benefit from minimal or barefoot running.

It’s probably true that my Brooks have neither helped nor hindered my performance and a quick review of my pace history has confirmed that fact. Before the Brooks I averaged, overall, about a 9:10 pace and that’s not far off from where I am today. All the same I am intrigued when I read running shoe reviews that mention certain brands and models, like the Mizuno Wave series, that are supposed to be highly responsive and provide a competitive advantage. This morning I decided to attack the real problem – the runner – and headed to the track for some speed work. I started out with a brisk warm-up at 6:46/mile for a quarter mile and then did 8×200’s at a little less than 6:00/mile. I finished up with an easy run at 8:54 for 1.25 miles, the pace seemed easy after all that high energy sprinting. I was happy that pushing that hard did not lead to any muscle pulls.

Would I do any better were I running with a pair of Brooks T-6’s or Vibram FiveFingers Sprints? Maybe, but I have to guess that they would cause as many problems for me as they would solve. In the meantime I’ll appreciate the comfort of my Brooks GTS 9’s and Asics 1130’s, the versatility of my NB 460’s, the rugged capability of my Helly Hansen Trail Lizards and the energetic feel of my Adidas Trail Response 15’s.

Me and my running shoes

On June 23, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

To many, gear is gear. A pair of running shoes is merely a tool to faciliate the run. In some cases running shoes are a necessary evil, especially for those who would prefer to run barefoot but don’t do that for practical reasons. I love running, that’s pretty obvious to anyone who reads this blog. But it’s not just running that I love, it’s all the cool things that come with that: new technologies to enhance the experience and the other gear that you need to maximize performance and comfort.

When I first started running I was relatively indifferent to shoes. I had no idea what was important when I went to Foot Locker for my first pair of running shoes. These would actually be my second pair, having bought some in the early 90’s during my earlier running days. I put myself into the hands of the saleswoman who admitted that she didn’t run but said that she fits runners all the time and knows what works for most. I don’t recall every shoe I tried on that day but the Nike Turbulence 13’s that she recommended fitted me the best. I had a great 500+ miles on those shoes but in the end. after inspection, I’d wondered whether their neutral nature played into the upper leg pain I had experienced near the end.

Including those Nikes, I’ve bought a total of four pairs of shoes since my return to running last summer. I bought a pair of Nike Kutu trail shoes that were inexpensive but never felt right. My last run in them was so negative that I immediately put them away for donation. I replaced those with a pair of New Balance 460 trail shoes. I haven’t liked the high-end NB shoes I’ve tried in stores but these 460’s are great. They were inexpensive but they’re solid performers with a good feel and nice response on both street and trail. No Gor-Tex or fancy features but they do the job well. I bought my Brooks Adrenalin GTS-9’s the day after my 5K in May. These are good shoes, not as responsive as the Nike 13’s they replaced but their stability properties have helped my upper leg problems. I’m not sure I’ll get the same shoes next time but I’m pleased so far.

The last pair I bought were Asic Gel-1130’s that I tried for the first time this morning. These are a few rungs down from Asic’s top line but they are far from low end. The fit is nice – more comfort than the Brooks but only by a little. I set out to do a mid length run this morning after icing both quadriceps and I ended up covering 5.13 miles at a 9:19 pace. I thought I might have run a little faster than that but the Garmin doesn’t lie (when calibrated correctly). The Asics felt really good and responsive and compared well against the Brooks. I’s say the Brooks are probably better overall in terms of feel but not by that much. I will enjoy having the 1130’s in the office, ready to take on whatever the streets of New York City can offer.

Give me the old soft shoe

On May 4, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

My Nikes served me well for Saturday’s race and it was almost with regret that I set out on Sunday to find their replacements. On the advice of experienced runners I decided to visit a local running store in Huntington where I could get some informed opinions on the right shoes to buy. The woman who helped me certainly had the right attitude and she looked at the way I walked and confirmed that I have a neutral stride. I told her I wanted a neutral cushioned shoe with a good response for a front foot runner.

I was given a number of shoes to try from Saucony, Asics, Brooks and New Balance. They all felt okay although I found one pair a bit unbalanced. After some trying and re-trying it came down to the Asics 2140’s versus the Brooks Adrenaline GTS 9’s. After some debate I chose the Brooks and took them home.

When I got home I looked up the shoes online and confirmed that the Brooks are more of a stability shoe for pronators (AG had warned of this) and the Asics 2140 had similar characteristics. I was deeply disappointed that I was steered toward this type of shoe despite my request for neutral cushioning. I spent the rest of the day deciding whether the Brooks, which felt okay, would be worth keeping. I ran with them on the treadmill and they felt fine but their responsiveness was not what I was hoping for. A big issue is the way they fit at the tongue, too tight against the front of my ankles. I felt like I couldn’t have the laces any looser without feeling some slippage. I also think I’ve diagnosed the problem with my Garmin, a low battery in the foot pod. I’m hoping to find a replacement for that today.

I tried the Adrenaline GTS 9’s again this morning and decided that I should be 100% happy with a pair of running shoes that cost twice what I paid for my trail shoes. Super Runners has a number of stores in NYC and their policy is to take back or exchange shoes if you’re not happy. I’m going to take back the Brooks and try on true neutral shoes until I find a pair that feels as good as the Nikes did when I first brought them home.

Turbulence about running shoes

On April 29, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

I’ve been paying attention to running shoes lately because I know I need to replace my current pair. Despite my attempt to preserve my Nikes by substituting the insoles I’ve learned (thanks to some helpful advice via the Runner’s World Loop) how to assess a shoe’s true condition. I’ve moved past the denial stage and have gone back to my original insoles. Although the Turbulence 13‘s felt great with the replacement insoles (after I cut them to fit) the difference in heel height made me worry about the possible effect on my knees since I’m a mid/front foot striker. I’m hoping that I can get one more great run out of these shoes at Saturday’s race.

With the original insoles intact I did what should be my last run before the 5K. I started at a moderate speed because I still have some upper leg tightness and wanted to warm up before stepping up my pace. I increased the treadmill speed every minute until I reached my target. Overall I covered 2 miles at 8:41, a pace I attained by running the last few minutes at about an 8:00/mile.

I’ve decided to go somewhat high end for my next pair of running shoes. Adventure Girl and others have advised me to look for shoes at running stores because those places carry better performing shoes than retailers like Foot Locker. My wife found some very good shoes at a Foot Locker as did I with my original Nike purchase. AG also told me that sometimes higher priced shoes cost more because of non-functional design elements. I don’t care what my shoes look like but if I can get 5 seconds per mile faster on them I’m happy to pay.

Running shoe anxiety

On April 27, 2009 By Emerging RunnerLeave a comment

I have 5 days until my next race and I’m beginning to worry about my shoes. I mentioned yesterday that I’ve had some issues with my feet that seem to relate to my Nikes. This morning I switched to my New Balance trail shoes for the elliptical and they were much more comfortable. I really don’t want to race with trail shoes on pavement but I also don’t want to continue pushing my luck with the Turbulence 13’s.

I have a busy schedule at work this week so it will not be that easy to get to a store at lunch to look at new running shoes. I want to avoid buying a pair in haste without considering other options just because of Saturday’s race deadline. I have been reading reviews and talking to friends and I’m thinking this is the time to invest in a higher end pair. AG told me about a few stores in the city that have treadmills so staff can watch you as you run and help recommend the best shoe choices for your running style. If I’m looking to pay a lot for a pair of running shoes I don’t want to buy the wrong thing and be disappointed.

I’ve looked at the removable soles in my Nikes and, while they look okay, I have no idea how much cushioning and flexibility they’ve lost in the eight months that I’ve had them. I’m thinking about trying a pair of cushioned replacement soles to get me through the race on Saturday. If they do the job, great. If not I’ll be paying a visit to a running store on Sunday.